The Ghost of Ebenezer

Last week three of my clients implemented staff reductions. All three are financially healthy service companies, but they had far more capacity than they had work to fill it. In a service company, of course, capacity means people.

Naturally there was considerable agonizing among the owners and managers about the timing of the move. While everyone involved in the decision process agreed with the numbers and the necessity, when the time came to name the names of people to be let go they balked. Some wanted to wait a bit longer to see if things improved. Some felt that the company had an obligation to keep employees until it was clearly unprofitable and deeply in trouble.

Many prevaricators, however, simply didn’t want to look like Scrooges by doing something now. They wanted to make the necessary business decision, but hold off on the announcement until just after the first of the year.

Why would you think that terminating someone in January would make them think you are a good guy? Most folks aren’t stupid. The normal lull in business activity at the end of the year isn’t a surprise and wouldn’t be the reason, so they would know that the decision was made some time before. As they thought about it, they would realize that at least some folks were toasting them at the holiday party and giving them best wishes knowing full well that they were dead men walking.

Then the January bills come in. “If I had only known…” they would say. I wouldn’t have bought so many presents. I wouldn’t have thrown that party. I wouldn’t have booked that airfare for a short vacation. I wouldn’t have blown my year end bonus.

I wish I had known when I went to those business open houses and our vendors’ holiday parties. There were lots of opportunities to network there, if someone would just have warned me that I needed to.

Finally, many if not most employees spend the holidays with family. The security and affirmation or loved ones is at its highest over the next few weeks. The common post-holiday let down isn’t a great base for dealing with a new shock.

There is never a good time to tell people that they are no longer employed. In a small business, where the owner knows every employee and probably their families, downsizing is especially painful. Making the decision and telling people after the holidays, however, is a special form of cruelty. Like the Santa Clause bonus bosses mentioned in my last posting, these are self-serving motivations. The boss just doesn’t want to look bad; to have folks think of him as cold and heartless when he is working so hard and spending so much money to look like a great guy.

Instead, let’s praise the boss who makes the painful decisions to protect the employment of the majority, even though those decisions may not make him look good personally. That takes courage and leadership.

Posted in Management | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Gifts are not incentives, and incentives shouldn’t be gifts

I knew a couple who owned a company with about 20 employees who had what may be the worst incentive distribution plan I’ve ever seen.

The company gave out large holiday bonuses every year at the company party, which was the last day before closing at Christmas. There was no documentation of how the amounts were decided, each employee received what the owners felt they “deserved.”

Worse than that, they gave out the bonuses by putting them in envelopes and hanging them from the company Christmas tree.

Wait- it gets worse. The owners had a standing family obligation for the holidays in another city, so every year they left the employees to celebrate on their own, and to open the bonuses together!

One year things had not gone so well for the company. They had eked out a small profit, but nothing like the highly successful year prior. The owners were determining bonuses, and each was running at about a third of the prior year’s amount.

The owners weren’t particularly concerned. The bonuses were gifts, after all, and they had no obligation to pay them. The employees certainly knew that it hadn’t been a great year, so further explanations shouldn’t be necessary.

They came to one employee who had worked very hard. He had really stood out that year, and was largely responsible for what success they’d had. The owners discussed it, and decided that he needed to be rewarded for his exceptional performance. Instead of a third of his prior year’s amount, they gave him 80%. Since they knew the employees discussed their bonuses, the recognition would be obvious to everyone.

The employee party went as before, with the envelopes distributed from the tree, and all opened at once. The high performer took out his check, read it, exclaimed “Those bastards!” and walked out the door. He never came back or spoke to another person in the company again.

A holiday gift should be just that, a gift. It should never be a major portion of the employee’s compensation. Even if your business structure dictates end of year incentive distribution, keep it separate from the holiday “bonus.” Give turkey, or a ham, or a check for $100 inside a card.

Gifts are gifts. They are tokens of appreciation. Bonuses are rewards for work performance, and must always be tied to specific goals and measurable objectives. In the case above, all the employee had to go on was a yardstick that said “I worked a lot harder this year and they appreciated me less.”

It’s weird how this time of year makes so many business owners start acting paternal (or maternal.) They run a great company 364 days a year, but for one day they want to play Santa Clause or Ebenezer (after the ghosts) by displaying warmth and largess and goodwill towards man.

That’s a great sentiment, but put it in the right place. In January you will want employees who understand they have a boss, not an extra Daddy or Mommy.

Posted in Management | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

2 Responses to Gifts are not incentives, and incentives shouldn’t be gifts

  1. Brad says:

    John, Merry Christmas! I continue to appreciate your insights into small business ownership and the disease of entrepreneurship. It is true that many of us struggle as business owners at this time of the year, missing the target and the meaning of the Season.

    Thanks for your continued friendship, and all the best for the New Year!

    Brad Elmhorst
    Direct Hit Data, Inc.

  2. airhawker says:

    Great post John. Sounds like our family business over the past 40 years! Your post definately opened my eyes and got me to re-think our holiday party and bonus program for tomorrow night!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

A 35K guy is a 35K guy…

I had breakfast with a client this morning. He was planning a new training initiative for his sales team.

“How much do the make now?” I asked. “About $30,000 to $35,000 a year.” he replied.

“What are you trying to accomplish?”

“I want them all to get up to between $50,000 and $60,000 a year.”

“Stop,” I said. “You are wasting your time.”

Now I expect all those who specialize in sales training and motivation will send me emails telling me that I’m all wet. I’m sorry. I’ve watched sales people for 40 years, and one thing is plain. A $35,000 guy is not a $60,000 guy.

I know a company that sells heavy equipment. They had several lines, but not the best one in the industry. The owner chased it for years, and finally landed a distribution contract. When I asked him how he was going to change his sales team he said “The only change will be that my salesmen who have been making around $60,000 will now make $120,000 to $150,000.”

He lost the line within 2 years.

All employees have comfort zones, and salespeople are no different. Although most will claim to have no limits on their financial ambition, most do. They have a lifestyle with a cost of living attached. Within that lifestyle and cost are the restaurants they like to frequent, the friends they feel comfortable with, the stores they shop, and their role in their family.

Success to most people is measured by a 10% or 20% income increase. They can get accustomed to that after a while, and of course then they want to do better. But if you give them unlimited opportunity, the majority of folks will taper off efforts at about a 20% improvement in their lifestyle. Beyond that and they have to start thinking about leaving their comfort zone. Most won’t do it.

That’s why owner after owner comes to me in frustration saying “I hired a guy and gave him the opportunity of a lifetime. He could have made $100,000 a year, and he just isn’t doing it. He’s never had an chance like this before and he is blowing it.”

Yup, and maybe next time he’ll be more ready to take advantage of it, but not now. He isn’t a $100,000 guy.

Posted in Leadership, Management | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

2 Responses to A 35K guy is a 35K guy…

  1. Paula Waxman says:

    John- Hope you and the family are well! I love what you wrote and it is absolutely true.
    I recently promoted someone to “take over” running the parties for my business which as a caterer, is a pretty significant move for me and for “him.” I am sharing 30% of the net from each party plus he receives pay for the party as well (about $120 bucks for each party). I have asked him to pursue bringing in business as well. He will receive an additional bonus for each gig he brings in. I can see that is where he will fall short, unable, uninterested or uncomfortable going out and selling. I think I offered way too much between the 30% and salary and now the incentive of an additional bonus isn’t really having an effect because he is making enough and certainly more than he has made before.
    I can’t afford to bring a salesperson in to this small business, that means it still falls on my shoulders.

    • John F. Dini says:

      Good to hear from you, Paula. I hope you are all doing well. Yes, there is really no motivational technique other than self-motivation. Those who have it look constantly to improve and do better (although it isn’t always money.) Those who are satisfied are satisfied. You can’t make them unsatisfied.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Attrition Opportunities

A client of mine used a great term in a conversation last week. Someone asked him if he had instituted any reductions in force (layoff, for those on the receiving end) in his company. “No,” he replied “but we’ve had a reduction in force via performance attrition.”

Performance attrition. Now that’s a GREAT euphemism for “Fired- for not doing the job.” It also serves as a reminder of something every business owner knows. Not every employee departure makes us sad. There are a number who we are happy to see move on, and a few to whom we have to give the final push.

One problem I see in smaller companies, however, is the tendency to replace people, rather than recruit to a need. When someone leaves, you have an opportunity to do much more than just “get someone better.” You can recast the position and duties to have a greater impact on your business.

In a small business most employees have to wear multiple hats. Over time, each employee winds up wearing the hats that suit him or her best. there are bookkeepers who double in customer service, or inside salesmen that handle the basic day to day computer set up chores. One of the attractions of a small business for many employees is the flexibility of the job description. People have more latitude to stretch. If you want to give something a try, it’s usually available.

But when that person leaves, we often have a job description that was custom built to that individual. Our current “receptionist” (I use that term only because she answers most of the phone calls and greets visitors) has a talent for graphics and writing. She has become the publisher of our newsletter. If she leaves, it would be a tremendous temptation to recruit another receptionist who can handle graphics and copy writing.

That would be foolish. We would not only be severely limiting the pool of candidates, but we would probably end up paying too much for the basic skills of the position. In truth, we’d probably either get a great newsletter editor or a lousy receptionist. Soon we would be customizing the job around the new person’s skills.

The departure (whether voluntary or involuntary) of an employee in a small company should be cause for examination of the position and its duties. What was assigned to that job because it was necessary, and what was assigned just because the person could do it, or liked it, or because someone else didn’t want it?

Start your new job description by peeling away all the duties that should or could be done by someone else. Ask what parts of the job other employees might like to give a try. Think about which tasks might once have been assigned elsewhere, but were picked up because the former employee volunteered when they became available.

Once you’ve stripped the position of its “optional” elements; you can see how much of a job remains. Is it a skilled position? Is it full time? Does it require a hire at all?

The best small business owners I know restructure their organization with every hire. Doing so spreads the opportunities, resets priorities, and increases profits.

Posted in Management | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jerry West on dealing with tough times

Sorry I’ve been away. Actually, I wrote this to post last week and forgot to publish it.

Lately I’ve been telling business owners a story from an interview I did with Jerry West during his tenure as GM for the Los Angeles Lakers.

Jerry said that he had been through good times and bad times. The good times were great; championship rings, parades, media. The bad times were tough. His wife hated to go shopping because strangers stopped her in the supermarket aisles to tell her what an idiot her husband was.

During either extreme Jerry received fan mail, some of which was quite articulate. When they won a championship, he was the genius GM. When they got ousted from he playoffs early (They didn’t MISS the playoffs from the time he became a player in the early 60’s until he left the team in the late 90’s- over 30 years) the letters would go into excruciating detail about his errors as a coach or manager.

Jerry saved the fan mail. He showed me two folders in his desk file drawer; one of great letters and one for really really bad letters (not the sickos- the intelligent “Let me explain why you are an idiot.” ones.)

When times were bad- a long losing streak or a big trade or a draft choice not working, Jerry took out a letter that proclaimed him a genius, to remind him that this too, shall pass.

When they won a championship, he’d make the time to read a few of the bad letters- to remind him that that getting to the top had a few bumps along the way.

In 2006 (seems a long time ago. doesn’t it?) many of us were buying into our own hype. I wish I had a list of all the business owners who told me “I’m making more money than ever before. I know exactly what I’m doing. Why would I need any advice or help?

Now the feeling of genius has dissipated for most of us. We have been reminded that we are all too human.

A business owner doesn’t need to pull out old letters. The reminders of the good times are all around us. A falling sales chart. Empty desks where we used to have busy employees. Idle trucks.

Turn the tables mentally on those reminders. Instead of brooding on what you don’t have now, look at them as reminders of what things can be when it’s all going right. You got there before, so you know that you can get there again. Then start planning on how to make it happen.

Posted in Entrepreneurship, Leadership | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

2 Responses to Jerry West on dealing with tough times

  1. Cheryl H says:

    Very poignant post. I agree that globally this seems to be the age of re-evaluation. With technology moving as fast as it does, the topics on which we are experts today could very well be irrelevant by tomorrow. You make a good point about not brooding, all we can do is rethink and move forward. Thanks again for a post, looking forward to your next!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *